Giving a Pet as a Christmas Gift, Explained

Last updated November 15, 2026
Thinking of giving a puppy or kitten for Christmas? Research found most gifted pets stay in their homes. Here is when a pet gift works and when to wait.
Key Takeaways
- A survey by the animal welfare group ASPCA found 86% of gifted pets were still in the home.
- Give a pet only to someone who has shown a lasting wish to own one.
- For children under 12, parents must be ready to care for the pet.
- The holidays are busy, so plan quiet time for the new pet to settle in.
Are Pets Good Christmas Gifts?
They can be, with the right planning. The old belief that gifted pets often end up in shelters is not backed by the research.
The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) surveyed people who got pets as gifts. Of them, 96% said the gift raised their bond or made no difference. That comes from the ASPCA position on pets as gifts.
What the Research Says
| Claim you may hear | What the ASPCA found |
|---|---|
| Gifted pets often get given up | 86% of gifted pets were still in the home |
| People bond less with a gift pet | 96% said the gift raised or did not change their bond |
| Surprise pets are a bad idea | Bond did not differ for surprise and planned gifts |
| Older studies disagree | Studies from the 1990s found gifted pets were less likely to be given up |
Would you like to get a pet as a gift?
- Yes, I would love it
- Only if I picked it
- No, I prefer to choose myself
- Not sure
When a Pet Gift Makes Sense
The ASPCA recommends pet gifts only in certain cases.
- The person has shown a steady interest in owning a pet.
- They can care for a pet responsibly, with time and money.
- You know their lifestyle and schedule well, if it is a surprise.
- They have free time to help the pet settle in.
When to Wait
Hold off if the person has never said they want a pet. Also wait if their home, lease or schedule does not allow one.
Gifting to a child? Parents should be ready to take on the pet’s care, especially for kids under 12, the ASPCA says.
Where to Get the Pet
Choose a shelter, a rescue, a friend or family member, or a responsible breeder. Avoid unknown or untrusted sources, the ASPCA advises.
The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) has a helpful guide to choosing the right pet. It covers costs, space and the pet’s needs.
Free updates
Join the Digieh list
Be the first to know when our weekly brief launches.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our Privacy Policy.
Get the Home Ready Before Christmas
The holidays bring hazards for new pets. Read our guides to holiday plants that are toxic to pets and holiday foods pets should avoid.
Cold weather matters too. See our winter pet safety tips.
- Confirm the person wants a pet
- Check that the home allows pets
- Choose a shelter, rescue or responsible breeder
- Buy food, a bed and a leash or litter box
- Book a first vet visit
- Keep holiday plants and foods out of reach
A Gift Idea That Lets Them Choose
Not sure the timing is right? Give a leash, a bed or a toy with a note promising a shelter visit together. The person then picks the pet that fits them.
Test Yourself
What share of gifted pets were still in the home in the ASPCA survey?
- About 30%
- 86%
- Under half
The ASPCA survey found 86% of gifted pets were still in the home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it a bad idea to give a pet as a Christmas gift?
Not always. An ASPCA survey found most gifted pets stayed in their homes. It works best when the person truly wants a pet and can care for one.
Should a pet gift be a surprise?
It can be. The ASPCA found the bond did not differ for surprise gifts. Just be sure the person has the time and means to care for a pet.
What should I give instead of a live pet?
Supplies like a leash or bed with a promise to visit a shelter together. This lets the person choose a pet that fits them.
Found this useful?
Editor’s Note
This guide is accurate as of November 15, 2026. It follows the ASPCA position on pets as gifts and AVMA guidance. Talk with the recipient’s household before giving any pet.
Spot an error in this article? Please contact us at support@digieh.com or read our Corrections Policy.
Keep exploring
Your next read is waiting
1EcommerceHow to Sell Your Old Stuff Online Safely4 min read
2HealthEarly Flu Season 2026 and the Essential Facts4 min read
3Pets & AnimalsPet Insurance Explained and What It Really Covers3 min read
4NewsAT&T and Verizon Satellite Service, What to Know3 min read
5TechnologyHow to Rotate PDF Pages Permanently for Free7 min read
6MarketingSimple Rules for Writing Alt Text That Helps8 min read











