Shopify vs Etsy 2026: Which Earns You More

Shopify vs Etsy 2026: fees side by side, two monthly cost calculators, a break-even table, traffic and control, and which platform suits your shop best.

Share this post
7 min read

Last updated November 20, 2026

If you are just starting and need buyers fast, pick Etsy. If you sell more than about 15 orders a month or want your own brand and customer list, pick Shopify.

Etsy brings shoppers to you but takes a bigger cut of each sale. Shopify costs a monthly fee and you must find your own customers. Run your numbers below.

Etsy monthly fees

Shopify Basic monthly cost

Digieh calculators using the $0.20 listing, 6.5 percent transaction and 3 percent plus $0.25 processing fees from Etsy. Shopify uses the $39 Basic plan and 2.9 percent plus 30 cents card rate from Shopify pricing.

Key Takeaways.
  • Etsy has no monthly fee but takes about 9.5 percent of each order plus small fixed fees.
  • Shopify Basic costs $39 a month, or $29 billed yearly, plus card fees.
  • At a $35 order, Shopify becomes cheaper at about 16 orders a month, by our math.
  • Etsy brings buyers. On Shopify you bring your own traffic.

Jump to a section

Shopify vs Etsy Fees, Side by Side

FeeEtsyShopify Basic
Monthly feeNone, Etsy Plus is optional at $10$39, or $29 a month billed yearly
Listing fee$0.20 per item, renews every 4 monthsNone
Sale fee6.5% of price plus shippingNone with Shopify Payments
Card processing, US3% + $0.252.9% + 30 cents online
Ads feeOffsite Ads 15%, or 12% for big shopsNone, you buy your own ads
Other payment providersNot offered2% extra fee

Source: Etsy fees page, Etsy Payments policy and Shopify pricing, checked November 20, 2026. Fees can change.

Etsy Offsite Ads charges a fee only when a sale comes from an Etsy ad on another site. The fee is capped at $100 per order, says Etsy.

What You Keep From One $35 Sale

ItemEtsyShopify Basic
Order total$35.00$35.00
Listing fee$0.20$0.00
Transaction fee$2.28$0.00
Card processing$1.30$1.32
You keep, before monthly fee$31.22$33.68

Source: Digieh calculation based on Etsy fees and Shopify pricing. Shopify also charges its monthly plan fee.

Per sale, Shopify keeps about $2.46 more in your pocket. The monthly fee eats that gap until you sell enough orders.

Digieh Break-Even Table

We priced a shop with a $35 average order, including shipping. The table compares monthly costs at different sales levels.

Orders per monthEtsy feesShopify Basic costCheaper option
5$18.88$45.58Etsy
10$37.75$52.15Etsy
15$56.63$58.73About equal
20$75.50$65.30Shopify
30$113.25$78.45Shopify
50$188.75$104.75Shopify

Source: Digieh calculation based on official fees from Etsy and Shopify, monthly billing, no ads. Yearly Shopify billing lowers the break-even.

16Orders a month at $35 each where Shopify Basic gets cheaper than Etsy, by Digieh math from official fees.
The hidden cost. The table leaves out marketing. On Shopify you may spend on ads or social posts to get those orders. On Etsy, many buyers find you through search.

Traffic: Who Brings the Buyers?

Etsy is a marketplace. Shoppers already go there to search for handmade, vintage and craft items. So a new shop can get sales without its own audience.

Shopify gives you your own website. Nobody visits unless you send them, through social media, email, search or paid ads.

That is why many sellers start on Etsy and add Shopify once they have repeat customers.

Brand and Control

What mattersEtsyShopify
Your own web addressNo, a shop page on EtsyYes
Customer emails for marketingLimitedYes, with permission
Store designBasic shop layoutFull themes and custom design
Competitors on your pageYes, similar items shownNo
Rule changes by the platformCan affect your shopYou control your store

Source: Digieh comparison based on the platform pages of Etsy and Shopify.

On your own store, you build a list of buyers you can email about new products. That list can be worth more than any single sale.

Where do you sell or plan to sell online?

  • Etsy
  • Shopify
  • Both
  • Not sure

Free updates

Join the Digieh list

Be the first to know when our weekly brief launches.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our Privacy Policy.

What Sells Best Where?

Good fits for Etsy

  • Handmade jewelry, candles and crafts.
  • Vintage items at least 20 years old.
  • Craft supplies and digital downloads like printables.
  • Personalized gifts.

Good fits for Shopify

  • A brand with its own audience on social media.
  • Products outside Etsy rules, like mass-made goods.
  • Larger catalogs with many sizes and colors.
  • Subscriptions and repeat orders.

Etsy limits what can be sold to handmade, vintage and craft supplies, with some approved production partners. Shopify lets you sell almost any legal product.

Who Each Platform Suits

Etsy suits you if

  • You are testing a new product idea.
  • You sell fewer than about 15 orders a month.
  • You do not want to run marketing yet.
  • Your items are handmade, vintage or creative.

Shopify suits you if

  • You already have followers or a mailing list.
  • You sell steadily and want lower costs per order.
  • You want full control of your brand and data.
  • You plan to grow into a bigger business.

Can You Use Both?

Yes. Many sellers keep an Etsy shop for discovery and run a Shopify store for repeat buyers. Shopify even offers ways to connect the two, though apps may add cost.

The main risk is inventory. If you sell the same item in two places, keep stock counts in sync so you do not oversell.

Payouts, Sales Tax and Paperwork

Both platforms pay sales into your bank account after a short holding period. New sellers may see longer holds at first while the platform builds trust.

In the United States, marketplaces like Etsy usually collect and send sales tax for you in most states. On your own Shopify store, you set up tax collection yourself, with Shopify tools to help.

Keep records of every sale, fee and refund for your taxes. A tax professional can tell you what to report where you live.

Common Mistakes New Sellers Make

  • Pricing without counting every fee.
  • Forgetting packaging and shipping supplies in costs.
  • Opening a Shopify store with no plan to get visitors.
  • Ignoring Etsy Offsite Ads fees on bigger orders.
  • Using blurry photos taken in poor light.
  • Not tracking which products actually make money.

A simple spreadsheet of costs per item fixes most of these. Update it every month as fees and prices change.

How to Start on Either Platform

  1. Write down your product, price and shipping cost.
  2. Run both calculators above with your real numbers.
  3. Start a free Etsy shop or a Shopify trial to test the setup.
  4. Photograph products in good light on a plain background.
  5. Write clear titles with the words buyers search for.
  6. Set aside money for fees, packaging and returns.

Keeping sales records? Our free Artlume tool turns receipt photos into spreadsheets. For fees in depth, see the real Etsy fees.

Starting on a tight budget? Read how to start an online store cheaply. Planning your money? Try the compound interest calculator.

Try this today. Put your real average order and monthly sales into both calculators. Write down which one is cheaper for you today.

Test Yourself

What is Etsy’s transaction fee on a sale?

  1. 3 percent
  2. 6.5 percent
  3. 15 percent

Etsy charges 6.5 percent of the item price plus shipping, on top of listing and processing fees.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Shopify or Etsy better for beginners?

Etsy is usually easier, since buyers already search there. Shopify is better once you can bring your own traffic.

Is Etsy cheaper than Shopify?

At low sales, yes, because there is no monthly fee. At about 16 or more $35 orders a month, Shopify Basic gets cheaper.

Can I move from Etsy to Shopify later?

Yes. Many sellers start on Etsy, then open a Shopify store and keep both.

Do I need a business license to sell on Etsy or Shopify?

It depends on your city, state and country. Check local rules before you start selling regularly.

Does Shopify have a free plan?

Shopify offers a short free trial, then a low intro price for a few months. After that, Basic costs $29 to $39 a month.

Conclusion

Etsy wins for new sellers who need buyers. Shopify wins for growing sellers who want lower costs per order and full control.

Your next step is to run both calculators with your own numbers. Then start where the math and your goals agree.

Editor’s Note

This article is accurate as of November 20, 2026. Fees come from the official Etsy fees page, Etsy Payments policy and Shopify pricing page. The break-even table is a Digieh calculation.

Spot an error in this article? Please contact us at support@digieh.com or read our Corrections Policy.

Keep exploring

Your next read is waiting

Found this useful?

Share this post
Avatar photo

Syed Wasif Raza

Syed Wasif Raza is the founder and editor of Digieh. He writes about health, food, lifestyle, news and sports in plain, easy English. Every guide he publishes is checked against official sources such as government and health agency pages. Connect with him on LinkedIn.

Articles: 717

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *