School Phone Bans: What Two New Studies Found
Do school phone bans raise test scores? Harvard found 1 to 2 extra weeks of learning a year. A second study found near-zero gains. Both studies explained.

Last updated November 21, 2026
A new Harvard study says strict school phone bans add about one to two weeks of learning a year. A second national study found almost no change in average test scores.
Both looked at schools that lock phones in pouches all day. The honest answer is that bans help a little, not a lot.
- Harvard found small yearly gains in math and reading, worth about 1 to 2 weeks of learning.
- The second study found near-zero average score effects, with modest gains in high school math.
- Suspensions rose about 11 percent in the first year of pouches, then faded.
- Bans clearly cut phone use in class. The learning boost is modest.
Jump to a section
- The Harvard study
- The second study
- Both studies compared
- Why the results differ
- What it means for families
- What happens next
- Frequently asked questions
- Conclusion
The Harvard Study: Small Gains That Add Up
Researchers at Harvard’s Center for Education Policy Research studied about 3.3 million students at roughly 4,600 schools. They used math and reading test results from grades 4 to 10, from 2021 to 2026.
Schools with strict pouch bans saw yearly growth rise by about one hundredth of a standard deviation. That equals one to two weeks of learning a year, says Harvard’s announcement.
The gains showed up in the first year and seemed to last three years later. They were similar across school levels, poverty levels and past results.
Lead researcher Tom Kane said strict bans seem to plug about half of the learning leak.
The Second Study: Near-Zero Average Effect
A team from Stanford, Michigan, Duke and Pennsylvania studied the same pouch schools in a different way. Their paper is a National Bureau of Economic Research working paper.
They found average test score effects near zero. High schools showed modest gains in math, while middle schools showed small declines, according to the paper.
- Phone use in class dropped sharply, from 61 percent to 13 percent by teacher reports.
- Discipline rose in the first year, with suspensions up about 11 percent.
- Student wellbeing dipped in year one, then turned positive by year two.
- Attendance did not change in a measurable way.
Co-author Thomas Dee called the early results largely disappointing, Utah public radio reports.
Both Studies Compared
| Question | Harvard study | Second national study |
|---|---|---|
| Students or schools | 3.3 million students, about 4,600 schools | About 4,600 pouch schools versus thousands of others |
| Test data | One national growth test, grades 4 to 10 | State tests for middle and high schools |
| Score effect | Small gain, 1 to 2 weeks of learning a year | Near zero on average |
| Best result | Similar gains at all levels | High school math |
| Other findings | Fewer big reading drops | Suspensions up about 11 percent in year one |
Sources: Harvard Graduate School of Education and National Bureau of Economic Research working paper 35132, not yet peer reviewed.
Should schools lock up phones for the whole day?
- Yes, all day
- Only during lessons
- No, let students keep them
- Not sure
Free updates
Join the Digieh list
Be the first to know when our weekly brief launches.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Read our Privacy Policy.
Why the Results Differ
- The Harvard team followed individual students’ growth on one test. The second team used school-level state test results.
- Different tests can pick up different kinds of change.
- Both found effects are small, so tiny method choices can change the sign.
- Enforcement varies. Some students hide spare phones or use school laptops instead.
Researcher Jean Twenge warned that weak enforcement may hide the real effect, Utah public radio notes. Time magazine asked whether such small gains are worth the cost.
What It Means for Families
Phone bans are not a magic fix, but they do cut distraction during class. Habits at home still matter a lot.
- Ask your school how its phone rule is enforced.
- Set phone-free homework time at home.
- Charge phones outside bedrooms at night.
- Talk with your child about social media, not just screen minutes.
Start with our guide on how to reduce screen time. For online safety talks, see how to talk to kids about online safety. Parents may also want our Instagram school program guide.
What Happens Next
More than 40 states now have laws limiting phones in school. Many began only in 2025 or 2026, so researchers expect clearer results with more years of data.
The Harvard team also suggests tracking engagement and mental health, not just test scores. We will update this page when new results come out.
Test Yourself
How much extra learning did the Harvard study link to strict phone bans?
- About 1 to 2 weeks a year
- About half a school year
- No change at all
Harvard estimated about one to two weeks of extra learning per year in schools with strict pouch bans.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do phone bans raise test scores?
One large study found small gains. Another found almost no average change.
Do phone bans cause more suspensions?
One study found suspensions rose about 11 percent in the first year, then faded.
Do students use phones less with pouches?
Yes. Teacher reports showed in-class phone use dropped from 61 percent to 13 percent.
Conclusion
School phone bans clearly reduce phone use in class. Their effect on test scores is real but small, and experts still disagree on its size.
Your next step is to pair school rules with phone-free habits at home.
Editor’s Note
This article is accurate as of November 21, 2026. Details come from Harvard’s November 2026 study and the National Bureau of Economic Research paper. We also used reporting by Utah public radio and Time magazine.
Spot an error in this article? Please contact us at support@digieh.com or read our Corrections Policy.
Keep exploring
Your next read is waiting
1TechnologyBusiness Card to Contact: Save Cards From Photos7 min read
2HealthPrediabetes A1C Range: What Your Number Means Now8 min read
3AI & TechAirPods 5 vs AirPods Pro 3: Which Wins?7 min read
4Pets & AnimalsCat Years Calculator: How Old Is Your Cat?7 min read
5Food & LifestyleElectric Blanket vs Space Heater: Which Costs Less?7 min read
6BusinessUS Chip Export Rule: Five Countries Need Licenses4 min readFound this useful?












